What makeup would look good on a pasty white red head?

Brown, frosty white, and other shimmery neutral eyeshadows would work. If your hair is so bright, stay away from any obvious colors (Like blue. Yech!). If you want a little color, try a dark, forest green eyeliner. I'm pretty sure MAC makes eye kohl in that color ($14). Line your top lid and the outer half of your waterline, and smoke it out so it looks black closest to the lashes and you see just a little green on the edges. Finish off with some black mascara and a rosey lip color.